
Who’s Remembered Here? Some of the Great Memorials at Carlisle Cathedral
This is a guest blog post by Ellis Kontkowski, university student on placement at Carlisle Cathedral.
Most of the names on Carlisle Cathedral’s monuments belong to bishops, deans and canons who have all left their mark here at Carlisle. Among them are a few people whose reputations reach well beyond the cathedral. Included within these are a philosopher whose famous argument for the existence of God is still debated over two centuries on, a poet who wrote in Cumbrian dialect and Scots, a clergyman who helped to save the Lake District, and a medieval bishop who once kept the Great Seal of England. This blog explores some of the people memorialised at Carlisle Cathedral as part of a research project to create an audio tour on the Bloomberg App.

William Paley (1743–1805)
William Paley was Archdeacon of Carlisle from 1782, and he is buried here in the Cathedral. He was one of the most widely read writers in the country during his lifetime. His View of the Evidences of Christianity (1794) was required reading at Cambridge for undergraduates for many years.
His most famous work is Natural Theology (1802), which contains an analogy that likens the intricate inner workings of a watch to those of the natural world around us and the human body. If a watch has a watchmaker, then the world around us must, by Paley’s logic, have an intelligent designer too.
The argument has shaped how many across the world think about nature and design. Charles Darwin read Paley closely as a student. His own theory of natural selection went on to offer a different explanation for the same evidence. Despite this, the watchmaker analogy itself is still considered very important today, and continues to be studied by philosophers, theologians and students.
Paley has two memorials at Carlisle Cathedral, one in the floor of the North Choir Aisle, and one at the east end.

Susanna Blamire (1747–1794)
Susanna Blamire was born at Cardew Hall, near Dalston, and spent much of her life in rural Cumberland. She is often referred to as the “Muse of Cumberland”.
Poetry in the eighteenth century was expected to be written in polished, standard English. Blamire wrote in it when she chose to, such as in her poem Stoklewath; or, the Cumbrian Village. She also wrote in Cumbrian dialect, the speech of the people around her, and in Scots. Moving between all three was very rare. Using regional speech in published poetry was a deliberate choice which gave weight to the way in which ordinary people actually talked, at a time when that speech was considered as something to be corrected.
Her famous Scots songs, such as The Siller Croun, circulated widely, and were often assumed to be the work of Scottish writers. Because she published almost nothing under her own name, her authorship was lost very easily. Her poems were not collected until nearly fifty years after her death, in 1842. Since then, she has been recognised as a distinctive and important literary figure in the region and beyond.
Her memorial tablet can be found on the floor of the south transept, just where you first enter the cathedral.

Hardwicke Rawnsley (1851–1920)
Hardwicke Rawnsley was vicar of Crosthwaite, near Keswick, and in 1893, he became a Canon of Carlisle. He was also a very energetic campaigner. From the 1880s onwards, he fiercely fought schemes that threatened the beauty of the Lake District, including proposed railways that would through the landscape and the industrial use of its lakes and fells. It was from these campaigns that he became convinced that persuading Parliament case by case was simply not enough. Places of natural significance and beauty needed someone who could own them outright and protect them for the public in perpetuity.
In 1895, Rawnsley, Octavia Hill and Sir Robert Hunter established the National Trust for Places of Historic Interest or Natural Beauty. Its first Lake District property was Brandelhow at Derwentwater, which was purchased in 1902 after a public appeal.
Rawnsley’s influence also reached famed author Beatrix Potter, a friend of his. Potter later became a conservationist in the Lakes, and when she died in 1943, she left more than 4,000 acres and fifteen farms to the National Trust. The Trust is now one of the largest landowners in the country, and a great deal of the Lake District landscape that we see today is now in its care. Much of that traces back to this Canon of Carlisle.
Rawnsley’s distinctive memorial tablet can be found on the south wall of the South Choir Aisle.

Silvester of Everdon (d. 1254)
At the eastern end of the North Choir Aisle you will find a fascinating stone effigy of a bishop, which is traditionally identified as being Silvester of Everdon, sometimes styled Silvester de Everdon. Silvester took his name from Everdon, a picturesque village in Northamptonshire, from which he came. Before he arrived at Carlisle, he had a career in royal service under King Henry III, and he held the Great Seal, which put him at the centre of royal government. He was made the Bishop of Carlisle in the late 1240s. Contemporary accounts suggest he hesitated to accept being installed as Bishop.
His time as bishop, however, was short. In 1254, he was thrown from his horse on the way back to the royal court and died of his injuries.
It is important to remember that medieval effigies were not intended to be perfect portraits. They showed the dead as they were meant to be remembered, here as a bishop in his vestments, carved in stone and laid out within the building he served. Whether the figure is definitely Silvester cannot be proved, but it is among the oldest memorials we can see in the cathedral.
Silvester of Everdon’s effigy tomb can be found just a little further east from William Paley’s floor tablet memorial.
These four examples are only a small part of the cathedral’s diverse collection of memorials. Its walls, floors and windows commemorate many people – some are well known, and many, less so.

How to Read the Memorials at Carlisle Cathedral
Many people read a memorial just for its words: a name, a pair of dates, and a line or two about the person’s character and achievements. It is therefore easy to forget that a memorial is, first and foremost, a made object. Its materiality, design and language were all very deliberate choices, and can tell you a great deal once you know what to look for.
Start by examining the materials. The Cathedral is built of local red sandstone, which is very easy to carve, but weathers and discolours quickly. Across the cathedral, you will find many memorials made out of different types of stone, including slate. In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, families who could afford it chose marble, which was imported from far and wide, including on the continent. It was very expensive and associated with classical sculpture and design, making it stands out against the cathedral’s red walls. Some memorials were carved in alabaster, a soft stone that was often quarried in the English Midlands. Brass, whilst popular in the Middle Ages, was revived by the Victorians as part of their great enthusiasm for the Gothic and Medieval. Some very fine examples of Victorian brass wall plaques can be found in the South Choir Aisle.
Then, look at the carvings. Urns are a symbol which were borrowed from ancient Greece and Rome, where they held the ashes of the dead, and later became a general sign of mourning on many Georgian memorials. The cloth often draped over them evokes the pall which is traditionally laid over a coffin. Some older memorials can be much more blunt. A skull serves to remind us that ultimately, everyone will die. A laurel wreath is traditionally associated with honour. Palm branches usually signify the soul’s victory over death, though in some earlier memorials, they can denote the person’s death as a martyr. The letters IHS, which appear in very many places around the cathedral, are the first three letters of “Jesus” in Greek, which is spelled as ΙΗΣΟΥΣ. These letters remind us of the hope of resurrection through Christ.
The use of language matters too. Latin has historically been considered as the language of learning and the Church, and some phrases are found everywhere when you look. Hic jacet means “here lies”, juxta sepultus est “is buried near this place”, in memoriam means “in memory of”, and requiescat in pace can be translated as “may he (or she) rest in peace”, the phrase which is the origin of RIP.
Some memorials are much more ambitious in their design. Effigies, which are often life-sized, carved figures of the deceased lying in prayer, were never intended to be fully realistic likenesses. They were intended to show a person as they wished to be remembered. If we compare the medieval figure in the North Choir Aisle traditionally identified as Bishop Silvester of Everdon with the Victorian effigy of Bishop Samuel Waldegrave in the cathedral’s East End, we can see how far ideas of remembrance simultaneously changed and stayed the same over the course of six hundred years. Many of the stained-glass windows are memorials as well, usually paid for by a family and dedicated in a short line of text running across the lower panels. They were very expensive gifts and keep the names of those memorialised in view of everyone who visits the Cathedral.
Next time you visit Carlisle Cathedral, try reading a memorial by its materiality and carvings before you look at its words!











